DIY Self Oscillating Class-D
Prototype no. 2
Prototype no. 2
Changes made over Prototype no. 1:
- Input filter changed to have the high pass DC filter
- Input cap changed to 2.2 uF to get a lower cut off
freq. of 8.1 Hz
- Two BAV99 diodes added to the input to act as over
- Input low pass filter changed to 50.7 kHz (from 159
- 220 uF added to decouple Vcc4 for the HIP driver.
- The delay resistors on the HIP Rdel changed from
adjustable to fixed
- All resistors changed to 805 SMD types
- Fast diodes across each MOSFET added
- Added a LM319 as part of the
oscillator instead of the built in comparator in the HIP4080A. This allows a
noise free start-up as the oscillator can star up before the disable pin on
the HIP is driven high and the power stage is activated.
- Most components changed to SMD types
to allow for a smaller PCB layout, which will improve noise performance.
- Diodes on gates
- Protection circuit added
- Snubber on output
- Snubbers on all power mosfets
Click here for the updated
The noise problems with the first
prototype, have almost been eliminated by adding signal diodes in parallel with
the gate resistors, placing a small cap between the two inputs on the
comparator, and adding more decoupling on the HIP4080 driver supply.
The layout is not optimal, and has too
long feedback traces. I'm not sure whether having the comparator in the same
chip as the driver is a good idea (but was reducing component count). It seems
that a lot of noise from the driver is coupling into the supply, and therefore
into the oscillator. This is one of the reasons I have chosen a separate
comparator for the second prototype. Snubbers will hopefully also minimize the
EMI radiation, which can also couple into the input and oscillator. An generally
use of SMD will give a more compact layout which will be less sensitive to
On the second prototype a protection
circuit was developed. The circuit consists of
- AC fall out detector (detection that
the amp has been turned off)
- DC detector (on speaker terminals)
- Over current
- Start up delay
The circuit was only simulated using
the following schematic, which is a bit different than the implemented circuit.
As will be seen it is though always a
very good idea to try out a new circuit on a breadboard, before including it on
As it turned out several parts of the
circuit did not work propperly.
Trial and Changes made to prototype no. 2
The finished PCB
measured from ground to one half of the full bridge.
The amp is running
on Vcc = 54 V
So far the amp is working
quite well. The sound is good, and there is not much noise to hear.
At turn on and turn off,
there is a bit of unwanted sound, but nothing critical. The turn on delay, and
protection circuit was meant to get rid of the unwanted sound all together, but
it turns out that it is not working that well, and I'll have to live with this
start up/turn off noise.
Compared to prototype no.
1, a lot of intended improvements have been implemented, and is working. The amp
seems good enough to be used as intended in my new subwoofer, and will with the
final power supply be able provide about 400 W into 6 ohm witch is the impedance
of Peerless XLS 12".
Next step will be to build
another of the amps, so that I can try them out as main stereo amps, just to
evaluate the sound properly.
Over current protection
It turns out that LM319 do not have
input range down to 0V as is required in the design of the over current
protection. The following changes are made to make it work anyway. See thread on
The solution from powerbecker is tried:
C34 changed from 100nF to 1nF
R57 is changed from 2k2 to 10k to lower
the bias current in Q13 (as I have forgotten a basis resistor!). This part works
anyway as the LM319 has an open collector and R57 will therefore work as a basis
AC fall out detection
It turns out the the AC fall out
detection circuit does not work. Doesen't really know why and didn't bother
finding out. Circuit disconnected.
DC detection circuit.
The DC detection circuit dos not work
under start up, as the DC level on both positive and negative out put will be
Vcc/2 before the circuit starts switching. The the DC detection circuit will
therefore prevent the HIP being enabled!
To make such a circuit work in this
construction, it should have been working differentially. In this case it
wouldn't matter that both outputs where at Vcc/2. On the other hand, a situation
where both outputs where at e.g. Vcc would not be detected!! Think the whole
protection circuit would be much better implemented around a small
The DC detection circuit has been
Delay resistors for the HIP
It has been tried to lower the two
delay resistors (R31, R32) to 47k, but the amp ran quite hot and also the
snooper resistors around the output mosfets, got really hot. Therefore the two
resistors where changed back to 100k. This means a little more distortion, but
better safe than sorry.
The switching frequency has been set to
some 213 kHz by changing R26/C5 to 1k/150 pF. The frequency changes with Vcc.
The higher Vcc the lower frequency.
At the moment the amp is running from
Vcc=54V, and as this is changed to 70V I will have to change R26/C5 to get the
desired 200 - 250 kHz.
Input limitation diodes
The two double diodes in the input, is
unfortunately placed on the wrong side of the input cap C3. Therefore the
oscillator was not working. The two diodes has been disconnected.
Start up delay
The start up delay circuit was changed
slightly to make it work. R41 was changed from 100k to 10k to make Q8 switch.
And C35 was changed from 100uF to 220uF as this was what I had. Delay seems ok.
Output coil "Bank" winded
Coil wound using the banking technique using 2 x 29
windings (not room for more!)